A PEO, or professional employer organization, is a company that becomes a co-employer of your staff. It shares certain employer duties with you, such as paying wages and filing payroll taxes, while you still run the business day to day. So can you use only some of what it offers? Partly.

You can't leave out payroll. Paying your employees' wages and handling their payroll taxes is what makes a PEO a PEO, and state PEO laws require it. Workers' comp often comes bundled, but in several states the contract can let you keep your own policy instead. Health insurance and a 401(k) are optional under the laws we checked, though a particular PEO may still require its health plan as a condition of signing. Everything else, from HR advice to software, depends on the PEO's contract. This article explains which parts are fixed, which you can usually leave out, and why.

The short version

  • Payroll and payroll taxes are not optional. If you want to keep running payroll yourself, you are looking for a different kind of service, not a PEO.
  • Workers' comp is the piece most often negotiated. Some states, such as Texas, let you keep your own policy. Others, such as Florida, require the PEO to provide it.
  • No law we found makes you take a PEO's health plan or 401(k). Some PEOs will still want you on their health plan as a condition of signing. Ask before you go far.
  • You usually can't put only a few employees on the PEO. The laws expect most or all of the staff in a location or unit to be covered.
  • Get a written list of what's required, what's optional and what costs extra before you sign.

Why you can't leave out payroll

All six state PEO laws we read make the PEO responsible for paying wages and payroll taxes. Florida requires the PEO to take on the payment of wages and "full responsibility" for payroll taxes. Texas says the contract "must provide" the same. Utah, Arizona, Ohio and North Carolina do too. So does the sample law that NAPEO, the PEO industry's trade group, wrote for states to copy. According to a 2024 report by Maryland's insurance regulator, 38 states have laws based on it.

North Carolina is the most direct. Its definition of PEO services leaves out payroll services where the company doesn't actually share your employees. A company that only runs your payroll is not acting as a PEO.

Federal tax law points the same way. A PEO approved by the IRS, called a certified PEO or CPEO, takes over your federal payroll tax duties for the wages it pays. The IRS chart of payroll arrangements says a certified PEO is generally the only one liable for those taxes. With an ordinary payroll service, you remain liable. A PEO that isn't certified is not covered by this rule, so the IRS can still look to you if the taxes go unpaid. Our guide to certified and non-certified PEOs explains the difference.

The same laws also give the PEO a right, shared with you, to hire, discipline and fire the workers it covers. Day to day, you usually still make those calls, and the contract says how the two of you share them. But the PEO's right has to be in it. You can't sign a PEO contract that leaves it out.

You can't usually pick and choose employees either

PEO laws describe the arrangement as covering "all or a majority" of the employees of a client, or of a division or work unit. Texas and Utah use the same words. The IRS rule for certified PEOs is stricter. For its special tax treatment to apply, at least 85% of the people who work for you at a given work site must be covered by its contract.

So putting only your office staff on a PEO while your field crew stays off it is usually not how it works. If you want to leave out a whole division or location, ask the PEO whether it can do that before you plan around it.

Service by service

The table shows each common piece of a PEO package and whether you can usually leave it out. We built it from the state laws above and federal tax rules. Each source is linked in the sections below and listed under Sources. If your state isn't one of these, ask the PEO which rules apply.

Which PEO services are fixed and which are optional
ServiceCan you leave it out?Why
Paying wages (payroll)NoEvery state PEO law we read requires the PEO to pay wages
Payroll taxes and filingsNoThe same laws require the PEO to withhold, report and pay payroll taxes on the wages it pays
Shared right to hire, discipline and fireNoThe contract must give the PEO this right alongside yours, even if you make the day-to-day calls
Workers' compDepends on your state and the PEOTexas, Arizona and North Carolina let the contract put it on you. Oregon lets you keep your own policy. Utah makes it your legal duty, though the PEO's policy can provide the coverage. Florida and Ohio require the PEO to provide it
Health insuranceYes, under the laws we checkedNo law we found requires it. Some PEOs require it to sign you
401(k) or other retirement planYesIRS rules say each client adopts the PEO's plan only if it chooses to
HR advice, handbooks, training, softwareDepends on the PEONo law sets these. They are whatever the contract includes

Based on the PEO laws of Florida, Texas, Utah, Arizona, Ohio and North Carolina, Oregon's workers' comp law, federal tax rules and NCCI's PEO guidance, read in November 2026. Other states may differ. This table is a guide, not legal advice.

Workers' comp: the piece most often negotiated

Workers' comp insurance pays medical bills and part of lost wages when an employee is hurt at work. PEOs often cover many clients' workers under one big policy in the PEO's own name, which is why it tends to come as part of the package.

The law is more flexible than that. In Texas, either you or the PEO can carry the coverage, and the contract must say which. Arizona and North Carolina also let the contract put it on either side. Utah makes the client legally responsible for having coverage, though the PEO's policy can supply it. In Oregon, the PEO covers your workers unless you have your own coverage on file with the state.

Two of the states we read go the other way. Florida makes the PEO responsible for providing workers' comp. Ohio requires the PEO to maintain it and manage the claims.

NCCI, the National Council on Compensation Insurance, writes the rules insurers use to price workers' comp in most states. It lists the ways a PEO client's workers' comp can be set up, and one of them is a policy you buy yourself. Even where the law allows that, the PEO can still say no. Our guide to PEO workers' compensation explains how the PEO's policy works and what it costs.

If your own workers' comp rate is low, ask whether you can keep your own policy. Then compare the total cost both ways.

Health insurance: optional by law

None of the laws we read require a client to take the PEO's health plan. In Texas, the PEO "may sponsor" a plan that clients' employees can join. North Carolina says the PEO may offer benefit plans and that the client may sponsor its own. Federal law doesn't require a certified PEO to provide any benefits beyond what its contract promises.

A PEO's health plan is one shared plan covering employees of many client companies. The Labor Department treats it as a plan shared by many separate employers, which it calls a MEWA, a multiple employer welfare arrangement. In plain terms, you would be joining someone else's group plan. That is a choice you make, not part of co-employment itself.

That is the law. In business terms, some PEOs only sign clients who join their health plan, and others don't. If keeping your current plan matters, raise it on the first call. Our guide to PEO health insurance covers how the plans work.

One federal rule applies only if you have 50 or more full-time employees, counting part-timers' hours. Below that, you can skip this paragraph. At that size, the Affordable Care Act requires you to offer health coverage or risk a penalty. That duty stays with you whether or not you use the PEO's plan. If you do use it, the PEO's offer counts as yours only if your fee goes up for each employee who enrolls. In other words, the PEO's plan only counts as your offer if you are the one paying for it. Our article on PEOs and the ACA goes into the details.

401(k) and other retirement plans

A PEO's 401(k) is a shared plan that many clients can join. IRS rules say the plan must be adopted by the clients that "wish to" take part. You can stay out of the PEO's plan, and state laws let you sponsor your own instead.

If you already have a 401(k), ask whether you can keep it. Our guide to PEO 401(k) plans covers both routes.

HR services, software and a la carte pricing

Beyond payroll, payroll taxes, workers' comp and the shared right to hire and fire, no law decides what a PEO must include. HR advice, employee handbooks, training, hiring help and the software you use are whatever the contract says. PEOs package these differently, so two contracts with the same name for a service can cover different things.

Choosing services one by one is what people usually mean by "a la carte." Some PEOs quote one bundled fee and others list each service separately. Our guides to PEO pricing models and bundled versus a la carte pricing explain how to compare the two kinds of quote.

If you want to stay the only employer, look at an ASO

An ASO, or administrative services organization, handles HR paperwork and often runs payroll too, but as your service provider, not as a co-employer. You stay the only employer, and payroll runs under your own tax ID. So the IRS rule for payroll services applies: you remain liable for your payroll taxes. That is the trade: you choose each service, but you keep the employer duties a PEO would share, and you don't get the PEO's group plans.

Our comparison of a PEO and an ASO goes into the details.

What to ask before you sign

Get these answers in writing.

  • Which services are required in your contract, and which can I leave out?
  • Can I keep my own workers' comp policy in my state? If not, whose policy will cover my workers?
  • Can I sign without joining your health plan? Does the fee change if I don't?
  • Can I keep my current 401(k)?
  • Do all my employees have to be covered, or can one location or division stay out?
  • Which HR services and software are included, and which cost extra?

Our guide to PEO contract terms covers the rest of what to look for in the agreement.

Talking it through

PEOs differ on which pieces they will let you keep, and it is not always on their websites. If you'd like help finding ones that fit how you want to work, you can request a consultation, and we'll connect you with our independent broker. It typically takes several business days. The consultation is free to you. If you sign through the broker, he shares part of his fee with us.

Sources