You vs. the PEO: Who Does What

Who does what when you team up with a PEO? Quick answer: co-employment means you run the business, and a Professional Employer Organization is the employer of record for taxes and benefits paperwork. It’s a simple split so you’re not buried in forms.

Co-employment in plain English

Think pit crew vs. driver. You steer, hire, and set the pace; the PEO tunes the engine of payroll, benefits, HR, and compliance so your small business runs smoother. When Anthony’s 11-person digital media company got busy, he stayed on clients while his PEO handled paychecks and forms.

You own these

  • Hiring decisions and who joins or leaves.
  • Pay rates, raises, bonuses, and budgets.
  • Work schedules and time-off approvals.
  • Culture, values, and how your team works.
  • Performance goals, feedback, and day-to-day supervision.

The PEO handles these

  • Payroll processing and payroll tax filings.
  • Benefits shopping, enrollment, and admin.
  • Workers’ comp policy and claims coordination.
  • Unemployment claims management.
  • HR compliance docs, notices, and records.
  • Onboarding/offboarding forms.

Shared/depends

  • Policy drafting and handbook updates: the PEO advises; you decide.
  • Investigations: the PEO guides process; you lead outcomes.
  • Safety training: the PEO provides tools; you run the floor.
  • Leave management (FMLA, PTO): the PEO helps; you approve.

Next step

Ready to map roles for your own team? Grab our comparison checklist or read: “What Does a PEO Cost?”

Searching For The Right PEO?

Get a FREE, tailor-made PEO match.

Partner with The Huldisch Group at zero cost. We’ll learn about your business, collect the necessary data, shop the top PEOs, and deliver a side-by-side cost analysis, so you can choose confidently without lifting a finger.

100% free, no obligation

Quotes & cost breakdown in 5-7 days

Expert guidance through selection & onboarding

Get my free PEO match